It’s a sunny afternoon, perfect for knocking out some errands. I get in my car, windows down, and grab a Supreme Leaf Toro (2023) I picked from my humidor—a 6 x 52 Nicaraguan beast from Aganorsa Leaf, priced at $13.99. The sunlight hits its Corojo 99 wrapper, and I’m already stoked for this medium-full ride. With my speakers ready to blast, I clip the cap and light up, letting the open road and this cigar set the vibe.
Let’s hit the gas and see what this stick’s got.
The Roots
Cigar Playlist
Cage the Elephant – “Ain’t No Rest for the Wicked” (2008): Gritty riffs for the sawdust and cake donut start.
Alice in Chains – “Man in the Box” (1990): Brooding edge for the wood and char depth.
The Strokes – “Last Nite” (2001): Punchy rock for the creamy pepper shift.
Jet – “Are You Gonna Be My Girl” (2003): Bold energy for the peanut butter fade.
The Verve – “Bitter Sweet Symphony” (1997): Soaring close for the creamy, balanced finish.
What the Pros Say
Cigar Aficionado gave the Supreme Leaf Toro a 92, raving about its balanced wood and spice. Cigar Insider scored it 89 for its smooth draw and Nicaraguan kick. Halfwheel called it a bold step for Aganorsa.90
The Smoke Stats
- Name: Supreme Leaf Toro (2023)
- Length: 6 Inches
- Ring Gauge: 52
- Vitola: Toro
- Wrapper: Nicaraguan Corojo 99
- Binder: Nicaraguan
- Filler: Nicaraguan
- Origin: Agricola Ganadera Norteña, Nicaragua
- Release Date: February 2023
- Price: $13.99/cigar, $139.90/box of 10
The Experience: From Start to Finish
First Look: Pre-Light Impressions
Cruising with the sun on my dash, I check out this Supreme Leaf Toro, a 6 x 52 stick that feels solid in hand. Its Nicaraguan Corojo 99 wrapper, a milk-chocolate shade with a leathery vibe, catches the light with a slight oily sheen and a few rugged veins. Aganorsa’s roll is tight, with a firm spring and a clean cap, screaming quality. The foot aroma’s bright—sawdust, light cake donut, apple pie crust, and a white pepper zip. The wrapper adds burning cedar and dry pretzels. The cold draw’s smooth, hitting with peanut butter on wheat bread and a light pepper tingle, priming me for a bold ride.
I light it up, speakers cranked, ready to roll.
Foot to Cap: The Flavor Journey
The first third hits with sawdust and light cake donut sweetness leading the charge. An apple pie aroma—more crust than filling—swirls around, while creamy, thick smoke fills the car. The medium-full profile’s lively, with a white pepper zing on the retrohale. The burn’s even but needs quicker puffs to stay lit, with a gray ash holding an inch. Compared to Aganorsa Leaf Aniversario, it’s less spicy but just as creamy, a bold Nicaraguan opener.
The middle third dials up the intensity. Wood takes over, with char and black pepper evoking a campfire steak. The wrapper shows small cracks, but they don’t unravel. Creaminess thickens after the first ash drop, boosting the smoke’s body. The cedar and dry pretzel aroma deepens, adding complexity. The burn steadies, draw smooth, though puffing’s still fast. Against CAO Flathead, it’s woodier, less sweet, with Nicaraguan grit shining.
The final third is a jam, blending creaminess, peanut butter on wheat bread, and light pepper for a smooth climax. Wood and char linger, with retrohales carrying bright white pepper and a hint of apple pie. The burn slows, ash holding to the nub, and the draw’s flawless for 80 minutes. Compared to Tatuaje Havana VI, it’s creamier, less earthy. The medium-full finish leaves a tingle, wrapping a bold, balanced smoke.
Build & Burn: The Craftsmanship
Aganorsa Leaf’s craft shows in the Supreme Leaf Toro’s build. The Corojo 99 wrapper’s smooth, oily, with faint veins, but it’s fragile, cracking slightly mid-smoke. The roll’s firm, cap tight, seams near-invisible, built for a premium $13.99 stick. The draw’s smooth, with creamy, thick smoke staying cool for 80 minutes. The burn’s mostly even, needing faster puffs early but stabilizing after the first ash drop. The gray ash holds firm, flaking minimally, showing solid combustion despite quirks.
Flavor Deep Dive: What’s Cooking
The Supreme Leaf Toro’s a flavor road trip, starting with sawdust, light cake donut, and apple pie crust sweetness, lifted by white pepper on the retrohale. Creamy smoke coats the palate, with Nicaraguan fillers adding depth. Mid-smoke, wood and char dominate, with black pepper and burning cedar evoking a campfire, while pretzel notes add crunch. The final third blends creamy peanut butter, light pepper, and wood, with bright retrohales of apple pie and spice. It’s bolder than Aganorsa Aniversario, creamier than CAO Flathead, a medium-full Nicaraguan rocker.
 |
Strength & Body: The Power Within |
The Supreme Leaf Toro’s medium-full strength delivers a steady nicotine buzz, perfect for seasoned smokers. It’s less intense than Aganorsa Aniversario but punchier than Tatuaje Havana VI. The body’s medium-full, with thick, creamy smoke carrying wood, pepper, and cream. The flavors balance spice and smoothness, ideal for a driving session with the windows down.
 |
Perfect Pairings: Elevate the Experience |
These pairings crank up the Toro’s 80-minute ride:
- Drinks: Woodford Reserve bourbon (matches wood); dark roast coffee (grounds pepper).
- Foods: Caramel toffee (echoes apple pie); salty pretzels (complements pretzel aroma).
Grab these for an evening chill.
Value: Worth the Price?
At $13.99 per stick ($139.90 for a box of 10), the Supreme Leaf Toro’s a premium Nicaraguan with solid value. Its complex wood, pepper, and cream justify the price, edging out Aganorsa Leaf Aniversario (~$12). The fragile wrapper and fast puffing dock a point, but the 80-minute burn and limited run (2,750 boxes) make it a steal for bold flavor fans. A box is worth it for collectors.
Our Rating:
 |
|
The Supreme Leaf Toro (2023) earns a Refined. Its wood, pepper, and creamy peanut butter deliver a medium-full 80-minute smoke. At $13.99, it’s a bold value, despite a fragile wrapper, perfect for seasoned smokers craving Nicaraguan grit. |
Final Thoughts
As I park the car, the Supreme Leaf Toro’s nub glows, wrapping up an 80-minute road trip banger. Grabbing this Nicaraguan gem from my humidor was a killer call—its wood, pepper, and creamy apple pie notes rocked my drive, with sunshine and grunge riffs cranking the vibe. Aganorsa’s craft delivers, despite a finicky wrapper. At $13.99, it’s a bold smoke that hits hard and lingers long, a must for any Nicaraguan fan.
Own the Smoke: Make It Yours
The Supreme Leaf Toro suits seasoned smokers craving a medium-full Nicaraguan with wood, pepper, and cream. Its 80-minute burn’s perfect for drives or evening sessions. With only 2,750 boxes released, it’s a hunt—check shops now, blast your tunes, and let this stick roll.
